Fall of 1975 - Larry Sharp
Fall of 1979 - Mark Sharp * 83 boxes
Fall of 1980 - Mark Sharp * 106 boxes
Fall of 1983 - Joe Westfall
Fall of 1985 - Andy Holbrook * 156 boxes
Fall of 1986 - Bart Poston
Spring of 1987 - Mark Gabriel
Fall of 1987 - Jeff Tilley
Spring of 1988 - Jeff Tilley
Fall of 1988 - Matt Noble
Spring of 1989 - Dave Thomas
Fall of 1989 - Corina Hyme
Spring of 1990 - Karen Kelley
Fall of 1991 - Dan Peters
Spring of 1992 - Doug Queen
Fall of 1994 - Kevin Pontius * 118.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 1995 - Ben Blosser * 118 boxes/baskets
Fall of 1996 - Jennifer Roush * 95 boxes/baskets
Fall of 1997 - Robert Blosser * 103.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 1998 - Robert Blosser * 129 boxes/baskets
Fall of 1999 - Robert Blosser * 108.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2000 - Heather Bussert * 100.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2001 - Chris Thornton * 73.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2002 - Heather Hines * 72 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2003 - Christine Bussert * 61 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2004 - Natalie Palmer * 75.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2005 - Josh Cordle * 60 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2006 - Josh Cordle * 54.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2007 - Tyler Van Horn * 76.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2008 - Sierra Jepsen * 56.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2009 - Nate Seitz * 86.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2010 - Nate Seitz * 110 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2011 - Nate Seitz * 92.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2012 - Susan Householder * 94 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2013 - Susan Householder * 164.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2014 - Susan Householder * 90 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2015 - Carlie Krile * 63 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2016 - Tanner Bennett * 78 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2017 - Cierra Andrews * 94.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2018 - Cierra Andrews * 73 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2019 - Cierra Andrews * 78 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2020 - Paige Alford * 60.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2021 - Braeleigh Blosser * 56.5 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2022 - Catherine Buckley * 65 boxes/baskets
Fall of 2023 - (tie) Kara Johnson, Alayna Leppert & Avery McKeska * 58.5 boxes/baskets